data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/c1172/c1172bce855f8eb56ea94453980049bd3d03ceb2" alt=""
Guy 2 showed up 15 minutes after Guy 1 left. He was late 20s, 6' 240#, and about 6.5uc. He also sported a wedding band, but didn't make mention of it. He was somewhat skiddish - asking repeatedly if anyone else was coming while he was being serviced. He was heavier in person than his photo indicated, but his foreskin made up for any feelings of being duped. There was so much skin, and it was so much fun to suck on. I could get my tongue all the way underneath it and he was super responsive to it. He asked me to use my hand too - which is not my favorite way, but he was the feeder. He got a little aggressive, and his breathing quickened. Pretty soon he shot a massive load - 8 really good bursts of cum shot out of his cock, washing down my tongue and heading into my gut.
Guy 3 was the real winner of the group. His email was direct - he wanted head, no recip, and didn't want to chat. I was good with that - hell, that's what I advertised for. He sent a photo that was INSANELY hot. He showed up on time, and his face was not a disappointment either. He walked into the room, took to the chair, and lowered his board shorts. I went down on him to get him hard, and he said, "Don't even think about ever using your hand." My kind of feeder! He got hard pretty quickly, and it was thicker than the previous two. His precum flowed quickly and with great taste. At one point, he pulled me off his cock, presented his wedding ring, and instructed me to lick it. I've never been asked to do that before, but fuck if I didn't almost shoot hands free from that. (I was fully clothed for all of these guys, btw.) He guided me back to his cock, which I took back into my mouth handsfree. "Good boy," he uttered, and then began to full-assault fuck my face. Without announcing it, he shot his load down my throat. What little I was allowed to taste was good. He had me lick his asshole when we were done. All in all, the winner, hands down.
Guy 4 was a late arriver, but a nice last contestant. He said he had a huge load, and listed stats as 5'7", 150# 6.5c. The pic that came with the email worked for me, and 25 minutes later he was at my door. He was the "gayest" of the lot, but still masculine. He poppered up and fed me his cock. He was pretty aggressive, but not quite as much as Guy 3. When the time came, he wanted to see his load - so he had me throw my head back and stroke him 5 strokes, so he could see his cum land on my tongue. I made a show of swallowing, and then cleaning his cock off.
All in all, a really good afternoon - the Craigslist Gods smiled upon me.